loveinc A world of stories
Search Latest Most Read Editor's Picks Archive About
US
US UK DE

lovePROPERTY

It’s Pumpkin Season in Miami! Pumpkin Key Private Island on Sale for $95m

The most expensive private islands for sale

By Abi Harman · October 12, 2023

Originally published on lovePROPERTY

Gallery View
Share
Follow
31 slides 13 min read
Private Islands Online

Luxury private islands for sale right now

For the super-rich, luxury mansions and enviable vacation properties are fairly commonplace. The ultimate way to showcase your wealth is to snap up your very own island paradise, particularly if that island is a one-off on some of the most valuable land in America. Pumpkin Key in Florida is on the market for an eye-watering sum and the chance to be a self-sufficient private island owner. Click or scroll through and let's take a look around...

Private Islands Online

Pumpkin Key, Florida, USA: $95 million

Known as Pumpkin Key, the 26-acre isle lies in the tropics of Card Sound Bay, in the Florida Keys. Perfect for millionaires, it's positioned a 10-minute helicopter ride from Miami's infamous South Beach and 10 minutes by boat to Ocean Reef, a private club in Key Largo, with an airstrip for private jets.

Private Islands Online

Pumpkin Key, Florida, USA: $95 million

Despite its close proximity to these popular spots, the island also provides plenty of privacy. Already developed, it comes with a main three-bedroom home, two caretaker's cottages and a dock master's apartment. Set up to be entirely self-sufficient, water and electricity are already in place, meaning you can move straight in!

Private Islands Online

Pumpkin Key, Florida, USA: $95 million

The island also boasts tennis courts, a helipad and golf cart paths. The listing agents, Private Islands Online, suggest a development plan, including the construction of a family compound with several large bay front homes. Alternatively, the buyer could create a private club or resort, with up to 12 homes. The choice would be yours!

Ready to cast away? From an exquisite eco island off the coast of Queensland, to a true paradise in The Bahamas, these idyllic spots could be yours – provided you can foot the hefty bill, that is! Ideal for billionaires in search of seclusion, click or scroll on to take a look at the exclusive private islands for sale right now...

Vladi Private Islands

Fort Morgan Cay, Roatán, Honduras: $9.9 million

Over in Central America, you could get your hands on Fort Morgan Cay for a cool $10 million. Located directly on a breathtaking coral reef in the Western Caribbean, this private resort island offers unparalleled natural beauty, space and tranquillity. 

Vladi Private Islands

Fort Morgan Cay, Roatán, Honduras: $9.9 million

Positioned in the heart of Port Royal Bay in Roatán, Honduras, this spectacular island is sandwiched between Port Royal National Park and the Marine Reserve, where sailing, hiking and world-class diving can be enjoyed. Spanning 33 acres, it comes complete with three white sand beaches, ruins of a 300-year-old pirate fort and 10,000 square feet of lounges, shaded terraces and sun decks. 

Vladi Private Islands

Fort Morgan Cay, Roatán, Honduras: $9.9 million

As if that wasn't enough, there's even a seven-bedroom guest lodge ready to be occupied. With perfect year-round weather, this island is the ultimate choice for those seeking a dreamy holiday home. The island is less than an hour's drive away from the nearest international airport and then a quick five-minute boat ride across the bay. It's also a two-hour flight from Atlanta, Miami and Houston. For sale with Vladi Private Islands, Fort Morgan Cay is sure to be snapped up in a hurry.

Vladi Private Islands

Isla Porcada, Panama, Pacific Coast: $10.8 million

This sweeping private island, fresh from the front of a postcard, can be found just off Panama’s Pacific Coast in Central America. Isla Porcada, as it’s known, is currently on the market for a whopping $10.8 million should you happen to be in the market for your own island near Chiquiri Province, complete with its own cattle and horse ranch…

Vladi Private Islands

Isla Porcada, Panama, Pacific Coast: $10.8 million

Numerous residencies populate the 2,471-acre idyllic escape, including the owner’s residence, a farmhouse, a caretaker’s house and four staff buildings. The island is fully self-sufficient and has the potential to be transformed into a golf resort or stud farm, though it's currently being utilised as a holiday retreat and ranch.  

Vladi Private Islands

Isla Porcada, Panama, Pacific Coast: $10.8 million

Fortunately, Isla Porcada boasts good phone coverage, a freshwater spring and a reliable electricity connection by means of its own solar power system. A boat is included in the sale, however, the isle does have an overgrown runway that could be restored and reactivated if you'd prefer to travel by plane. Plans are also in place to add a guest house to the island’s plateau, should you want visitors that is… 

Sotheby's International Realty

Turnagain Island, British Columbia, Canada: $11.4 million

If you prefer a milder climate, then how about Turnagain Island? Located in the heart of Secret Cove in Halfmoon Bay, British Columbia, the forested isle stretches almost 95 acres and has been curated by the same family for over 60 years.

Sotheby's International Realty

Turnagain Island, British Columbia, Canada: $11.4 million

The island isn't just a paradise of forest and coast, either. It comes complete with two lovely homes that are move-in ready. The first is a custom-built post and beam residence that spans 3,000 square foot. It features a gorgeous interior with four bedrooms, three bathrooms, a chef's kitchen and a stunning living room with a floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace. 

Sotheby's International Realty

Turnagain Island, British Columbia, Canada: $11.4 million

The off-grid property also has soaring beamed ceilings and extensive glass, allowing for unobstructed views from almost every room. The second property is older and measures approximately 2,800 square feet. It has an open-concept interior with four bedrooms, three bathrooms and a large living area. For the listing price of $11.4 million, you'll also acquire two docks, submarine hydropower, a private reservoir for irrigation, high-end security and several garages that could be converted.

Private Islands Online

Pumpkin Island, Queensland, Australia: $14 million

If you fancy relocating to Australia, then perhaps Pumpkin Island will take your fancy. Nestled near the Southern Great Barrier Reef in Queensland, this pristine strip of land has been described by the listing agents, Private Islands Online, as "one of Australia’s best-kept secrets".

Private Islands Online

Pumpkin Island, Queensland, Australia: $14 million

Covering 15 acres, the island is just off the coast of Yeppoon and is home to a stunning eco-friendly vacation retreat, designed for couples and VIP holidaymakers. At any one time, you could host up to 34 guests on your new private island thanks to its five self-contained oceanfront cottages with their own outdoor decks, plus two bungalows with outdoor kitchens.

Private Islands Online

Pumpkin Island, Queensland, Australia: $14 million

The off-grid Australian retreat is entirely powered by solar and wind, but also comes equipped with plenty of rainwater storage for reuse. Pumpkin Island was named Australia’s most sustainable hotel in 2018 at the World Boutique Hotel Awards and was the first beyond carbon neutral island in the country, offering buyers the chance to take over the reins of this thriving eco-resort. Plus, with scenery like this what more could you possibly need?

Private Islands Online

Hummingbird Cay, Exuma, The Bahamas: $35 million

If you've always wanted to own a true piece of tranquillity, now's your chance. This incredible private island in the region of Exuma in The Bahamas is a picture-postcard paradise. Known as Hummingbird Cay, the strip of land spreads some 175 acres and is only five miles from the main island of Great Exuma, making it the ultimate secret holiday escape for those looking to fly under the radar.

Private Islands Online

Hummingbird Cay, Exuma, The Bahamas: $35 million

The island is surrounded by crystal clear waters and what has been described as an "ever-changing view" of sandbars, reefs and the sky. Hummingbird Cay comes equipped with a 2,500-foot-long white sandy beach, two smaller beaches and endless diving, fishing and sailing opportunities. While most of the island is undeveloped, there are several homes ready and waiting for you to put to use.

Private Islands Online

Hummingbird Cay, Exuma, The Bahamas: $35 million

As well as a 1,700-square-foot main house, there are also three guest lodges, numerous utility buildings and staff accommodation, so you could bag yourself land with a job thrown in. There are a total of 10 bedrooms, 10 bathrooms and 5,000 square feet of interior space. What's more, off-grid solar energy powers the island and phone and internet facilities are already in place. All you need now is $35m million, your swimsuit and a toothbrush!

Sotheby's International Realty

Crown Pigeon Island, Eleuthera, The Bahamas: $44.5 million

Looking for another private paradise? Why not try Crown Pigeon Island? Found in Eleuthera, The Bahamas, with a $44.5 million price tag, the 11-acre archipelago benefits from stunning white-sand beaches to the west and aquamarine shallows to the east, making it a true haven for nature lovers.

Sotheby's International Realty

Crown Pigeon Island, Eleuthera, The Bahamas: $44.5 million

The island benefits from three natural beaches, as well as a restaurant and bar that could easily be renovated and opened up to tourists. Dotted across the island you'll find an array of stunning waterfront homes, too – there are five modern cottages, three plush villas and two infinity pools, not to mention jaw-dropping views.

Sotheby's International Realty

Crown Pigeon Island, Eleuthera, The Bahamas: $44.5 million

As well as unrivalled outlooks, the accommodation comes complete with several patios, courtyards, gardens and outdoor kitchens, so you can host events, weddings and holidaymakers with ease. Getting there is easy, too: there's a large harbour with a 50-foot turning radius and enough dock space for five large vessels. Available through Sotheby's International Realty, this remarkable private island is definitely a piece of paradise.

Private Islands Online

Royal Island, Eleuthera, The Bahamas: $45 million

If you have a bigger budget to work with, how about Royal Island, also in Eleuthera in The Bahamas? Up for grabs for a colossal $45 million, this billionaire bolthole is ready and waiting for you and all your VIP friends.

Private Islands Online

Royal Island, Eleuthera, The Bahamas: $45 million

For sale with Private Islands Online, the luxurious strip of land stretches for 430 acres and can be found just off Russell Island in North Eleuthera. Home to spectacular beaches, luxurious private villas and a huge natural harbour, Royal Island is a turnkey resort that was created in 2007. It's been in operation ever since, making this ideal for someone looking to swoop in and take over the reins of a successful hospitality business. 

Private Islands Online

Royal Island, Eleuthera, The Bahamas: $45 million

The island boasts five separate one-bedroom villas, each with a beautiful wraparound deck. Modern and inviting, each home can be found within touching distance of the water. There's also a welcome center, spa, gym, restaurant and bar, as well as a beach club, private catamaran and security facilities. What's more, the oasis lies less than 20 minutes away from North Eleuthera's international airport. So, what are you waiting for?

Sotheby's International Realty

Water Cay Private Island, Water Cay, Turks and Caicos: $44.5 million

If you'd prefer to holiday in the Atlantic archipelago of Turks and Caicos, then look no further. Water Cay has just hit the market with a $44.5 million price tag. For that sizeable sum, you'll gain 432 pristine private acres of land and 7,000 feet of uninterrupted beach frontage – this is a luxurious remote property that any celebrity would be proud to own.

Sotheby's International Realty

Water Cay Private Island, Water Cay, Turks and Caicos: $44.5 million

Offering the best of both worlds, Water Cay is secluded but also lies just a 10-minute boat ride from Leeward Channel Marina, which in turn is a 15-minute car ride from Provo International Airport. Described by Sotheby's International Realty as the "finest private or commercial development opportunity" in all of Turks And Caicos, the luxurious piece of land comes complete with a welcome center and a 3,000-square-foot office building in neighboring Grace Bay.

Sotheby's International Realty

Water Cay Private Island, Water Cay, Turks and Caicos: $44.5 million

The island boasts its own harbour and three untouched beaches: Half Moon Bay, Little Water Cay and Pine Cay. What’s more, the north shore provides the perfect foundations to build a luxury home. The pristine plot also provides access to sandy cliffs, crystal-clear waters and mangrove wetlands, so there's plenty of natural landscapes to explore.

Vladi Private Islands

Vatuvara Private Islands, Lau Group, Fiji: $155 million

Located in one of the world's most beautiful places, as described by Forbes, the Vatuvara Private Islands can be found in the Northern Lau Group of Fiji. Totalling 5,187 acres, this incredible real estate opportunity is not for the faint-hearted – or those on a budget. On the market with Vladi Private Islands for an eye-watering $155 million, there's plenty of bang for your buck with this set of luxurious islands...

Vladi Private Islands

Vatuvara Private Islands, Lau Group, Fiji: $155 million

For your money, you'll obtain the 1,200-acre Vatuvara Island, the 800-acre Kaibu Island, the 3,085-acre Kanacea Island and the 102-acre Adavaci Island, as well as a Twin Otter aircraft, so you can island-hop or make a speedy getaway whenever the need arises. Talk about a home that comes with a surprising extra!

Vladi Private Islands

Vatuvara Private Islands, Lau Group, Fiji: $155 million

The islands have been run as a highly successful private resort for many years, seducing VIPs with their pristine white-sand beaches, tropical gardens, picturesque lagoons and coral reefs. Accommodation-wize, you're all set. There are endless incredible villas dotted across these isles, many of which are powered by solar and come with private swimming pools, jaw-dropping views and deluxe interiors. The sale also includes numerous high-end restaurants and bars. 

Reference links to original sources may not appear in this version – to view the piece in full, please see www.loveproperty.com

The Love Inc Weekly

Get this week's biggest stories

Hand-picked every Thursday from loveMONEY, loveFOOD, lovePROPERTY and loveEXPLORING.

  • 100% free
  • No spam, ever
  • Join 1M+ readers

love inc.

This week's biggest stories

1m+ follow love Inc.

Most popular this week
loveMONEY loveFOOD lovePROPERTY loveEXPLORING

Related reads

Back home
30 Delicious Pumpkin Recipes to Try All Year Round

loveFOOD

30 Delicious Pumpkin Recipes to Try All Year Round

Laura Ellis Jan 29, 2025

30+ Awesome Pumpkin Décor Ideas You'll Love

lovePROPERTY

30+ Awesome Pumpkin Décor Ideas You'll Love

Rachel Homer Sep 30, 2024

Incredible black-and-white images tell the story of Miami

loveEXPLORING

Incredible black-and-white images tell the story of Miami

Richard Jones Nov 1, 2025

Kylie Jenner's $95m Property Portfolio Includes a HUGE New Project

lovePROPERTY

Kylie Jenner's $95m Property Portfolio Includes a HUGE New Project

Abi Harman Jun 2, 2023

Miami's 14 Most Unmissable Things To See And Do

loveEXPLORING

Miami's 14 Most Unmissable Things To See And Do

Alice Cattley Oct 2, 2024

Ranked: The Top 37 Places In America For An Off-Season Vacation

loveEXPLORING

Ranked: The Top 37 Places In America For An Off-Season Vacation

Ella Buchan Jun 19, 2025

Love Everything?

Explore more topics from our expert writers, from money and food to travel and home.

loveMONEY loveFOOD loveEXPLORING lovePROPERTY

Copyright © loveINC. All rights reserved.

About Contact Terms of use Privacy policy Disclaimer

We use analytics cookies to understand how visitors use loveINC and improve the site. We don't use any advertising cookies. See our privacy policy for details.